60k in San Diego would be considered a working or lower-middle-class income.
Mayor Todd Gloria Reveals 22 Members of Middle - Times of San Diego What Is Middle-Class Income? - The Balance The Pew Research Center defines the US middle class as those earning 67% to 200% of the median household income. FAMILY SIZE 80% of AMI. The Middle Class Scholarship (MCS) provides undergraduate students, including students pursuing a teaching credential, with a scholarship to attend a University of California (UC) or California State University (CSU) campus.
Where Do I Fall in the American Economic Class System? For a single individual, a middle-class income ranges from $30,000 . Persons in Household. How much does an Upper Class make in San Diego, California? That would place the middle class between $33,761 and $101,281, based on the Census median income of $67,521. The new RHNA for 2020 to 2029 calls for 19,319 new middle-income units, but only three were built in 2020 and only 19 last year. 2-person family middle-class income range: $46,216 to $137,958. Middle-wage job and income losses were deeper in San Diego than in . Chart. I make $50k a year and it's in San Diego and I have 740 credit score with no debt. Show dollars as: Nominal Real. The annual area median income for San Diego County according to the San Diego Housing Commission is $77,900 for one person, $89,000 for a two-person household, $100,150 for a three-person household, and $21,250 for a family of four, according to federal Housing and Urban Development figures. While ZipRecruiter is seeing salaries as high as $105,144 and as low as $20,516, the majority of salaries within the Upper Class jobs category currently range between $39,492 (25th percentile) to $68,727 (75th percentile) with top earners (90th percentile) making $85,140 annually in San Diego. This income calculator will tell you. That ranged from $48,500 to $145,500 in 2018. A new study from the Pew Research Center says the American middle class is stable in size but is slowly losing ground due to upper-income families. However, Black, Latinx, and Native American households .
Middle Class Scholarship | Student Affairs | SDSU - San Diego State What is considered middle class income in San Diego? Is $60,000 a year a middle class income in California? By definition it is but quality of life means different things to different people. . Map. The total share of household income in Minnesota controlled by middle-class earners is 48%, 24/7 Wall St. reports. The site used U.S. Census Bureau income data to determine the salary a household needs to earn to be in the city's top 20% of earners - what they define as "rich.". While public schools are free to attend, private school tuition will set parents back $8,863 on average for elementary schools and $24,175 on average for high schools. What is a middle class salary in 2020? A middle class lifestyle should include owning you own median-priced home. In 1980, 60 . The Pew Research Center defines the US middle class as those earning 67% to 200% of the median household income. Therefore, you can add $24,000 a year in forced savings to their $37,000 a year in 401 (k) savings. Very Low Income. How to solve a middle-class housing shortage?
What Is Middle-Class Income in the Biggest US Cities - Business Insider Upper Class Salary in San Diego, CA - ZipRecruiter Embed . Moving to San Diego (middle-class, income, to live) User Name: Remember Me: Password : Please . Middle Class Scholarships will be based on a sliding scale according to family income. The home you buy must be your primary residence. Qualified buyers' family income must not exceed 80 percent of the San Diego County Area Median Income, also called the AMI. The unemployment rate in San Diego is 7% higher than the national average. 3-person family middle-class income range: $55,882 to $166,812. But despite these differences, you can still find places where America's middle class is thriving. Middle-class Americans earned about $40,425 to $120,672 . A dire warning from the head of San Diego County's Building Industry Association, the county may never again see the construction of middle-income housing. For a .
What Is Middle Class Income? The Latest Numbers Available - Investopedia The new RHNA for 2020 to 2029 calls for 19,319 new middle-income units, but only three were built in 2020 and only 19 last year. Print.
Are you middle class? This calculator tells you - KGTV This is the equivalent of $1,222/week or $5,296/month.
What qualifies as low income in San Diego? - 2022 In other words, everyone from 30% below the median income to 30% above it. $32,794 to $98,380. The purchase price may not exceed $589,000, subject to periodic adjustments. Between 2019 and 2020 the population of San Diego, CA grew from 1.41M to 1.41M, a 0.353% increase and its median household income grew from $79,673 to $83,454, a 4.75% increase. San Diego San Diego County California United States of America North America Place. 4-person family middle-class income range: $52,059 to $155,400. For a family of four in 2022, that range is $97,000 to $142,650. Students may not recieve other grants & fee-paying sources.
Middle class income in the US by cities. Middle class income in the US San Diego; Santa Barbara; Santa Cruz; Campus program & support services. Middle Class Income Calculator for Major Metropolitan Areas, Cities and States in the United States (2012 Data) . "The key group leaving is basically in their 30s, 40s and 50s tending to be making about $100,000 to . Table. (The data is in 2016 dollars before taxes. The loan funds must be used to pay a down payment and closing costs on the purchase.
What qualifies as low income in San Diego? - 2022 10-16-2009, 09:12 AM Just1Lion : Location: stuck. Some Silicon Valley residents earning $400,000 consider themselves to be in the middle class, a recent survey found. For high earners, a three-person family needed an income between $106,827 and $373,894 to be considered upper-middle .
No Longer Golden: As Costs Rise, More Middle - Times of San Diego U.S. Census Bureau QuickFacts: San Diego city, California Students with family income and assets up to $201,000 may be eligible. Clear 1 Table. Pew defines the middle class as households that have an annual pre-tax income that is at least two-thirds to double the national median.
How San Diego plans to solve a middle-class home shortage - Point Loma What is considered middle class in Minnesota? - 2022 30% of AMI. The median household income in the City of San Diego increased by 1.5% in 2018, but these increases weren't evenly distributed, with Native American, Asian, and Latinx households experiencing decreases between 3-5%. 1.
Living Wage Calculation for San Diego County, California The city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of the region's median income. March 31st, 2019 at 12:47 am.
How San Diego plans to solve a middle-class home shortage - La Jolla Light San Diego bets on reforms, incentives . Median household income (in 2020 dollars), 2016-2020: $83,454: December 14, 2021 by Trevor Zboncak. So she estimates the middle-class income in Los Angeles County for a family of four renting a house between $ 65,030 and $ 227,605. (Currently . (rent, condo) User Name: Remember Me: Password . By Benjamin Yates / August 15, 2022 August 15, 2022. Oakland: Median household income $63,251, middle-class . Middle Class. My first interest, of course, has to do with San Diego home sales and where San Diego's 2013 median income is $71,000 among "families" where two or more people are related by birth, marriage or adoption. While funding sources exist to develop low-income housing and housing affordable to To be eligible, students must be enrolled at minimum half time, have a family income less than or equal to $184,000 and cannot have household assets over $184,000. These are the typical annual salaries for various professions in this location. In 2018, according to the U.S. Census, 38,000 more people left the Golden State than moved there for the second year in a row.
Poverty, Income, and Earnings in the City of San Diego, 2018 San Diego County has a median income of $77,900 for one person .
California's middle class is in decline, despite the state's immense 2-person family middle-class income range: 3-person family middle-class income range: . This will depend on family size.
Is San Diego better than Los Angeles? - san-diego.biz San Diego suffers from a lack of housing built for families earning between 80% and 150% of the area median income $97,000 to $142,650 for a family of four. A family earning between $32,048 and $53,413 was considered lower-middle class. That ranged .
How San Diego plans to tackle a middle-class home crunch The middle class has shrunk to include less than half of all Californians, according to a new report from the Public Policy Institute of California (PPIC). The latest census numbers indicate what income ranges constitute the middle class (as of 2020). How much income do you need to live a middle class lifestyle in San Diego? Dec. 8, 2011.
What Is Considered A Low Income Household In San Diego? The 23-member experts panel, which met several .
San Diego County launches programs to prevent senior homelessness, help 4-person family middle-class income range: $52,438.89 to . What's considered low What Is Considered A Low Income Household In San Diego . The city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of the region's median income. FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, Sept. 9, 2021 CONTACT: MayorPress@sandiego.gov SAN DIEGO .
What Is Upper Class Income In San Diego? - PartyShopMaine What is Middle Class in San Diego? - sandiegopreviews.com 2-person family middle-class income range: $37,172.94 to $110,964. Subscribe Form Subscribe to Blog. Roughly three-in-ten (29%) were in lower-income households and 19% were in upper-income households.
The San Diego Cost of Living - UpNest Subscribe: Comments; Subscribe . 33. "I'm proud to assist Mayor Gloria in his effort to make housing more affordable to middle-income San Diegans." San Diego suffers from a lack of housing built for families earning between 80 percent and 150 percent of the area median income . Since 2010, median income has increased by 15% for the City of San Diego. The most . For students with family income . Wisconsin. Our calculator below, updated with 2018 data, lets you find out . The median household income in San Diego is 23% higher than the national average. You can see in the chart below how much .
What Income Level Is Considered Middle Class in Your State? - Yahoo! Is an annual salary of $192,000 'middle class' in SF? - Curbed SF America's middle-class ranges from $35,000 to $122,500 in annual income, according to The Post's calculation.
Opinion: Here's how we can help middle-income families in San Diego buy Dashboard. Low Income.
What Is A Middle Class Income For A Single Person? - CLJ Utilizing HUD's definition, affordable housing for a low-income family (household earning up to 80 percent of San Diego area median income) (AMI), would be an apartment renting for about $1,500 per month or a home priced under $225,000. Population; Income & Poverty: Median household income (in 2019 dollars), 2015-2019: $79,673: Per capita income in past 12 months (in 2019 dollars), 2015-2019: $41,112: Persons in poverty, percent 12.8%: What is moderate income in California? Just in case you need a simple salary calculator, that works out to be approximately .
Moving to San Diego (middle-class, income, to live) - City-Data Middle-income workers make too much money to qualify for low-income programs but often don't make enough to afford a home.
Middle Class Housing Fund Started - San Diego Business Journal Email. 4-person family middle-class income range: $66,791 to $199,376. People who work in the business . The number of middle-income Americans slipped from 61 percent in 1971 to 50 percent in 2015, according to the Pew Research Center.
San Diego's Housing Crisis Squeezing The Middle Class For a family of four in 2022, that range is $97,000 to $142,650. What is middle class income in San Diego? Private sector developers built these homes. LEAVE A COMMENT. A new program passed by San Diego County Board of Supervisors on Tuesday creates incentives to build affordable housing and provides help to homebuyers and renters.
Middle Class Incomes by Metropolitan Areas (Cities States) "They might be making $70,000, $80,000, or $100,000 but the average home . San Diego city, California. Here's the breakdown across the Bay Area: San Francisco: Median household income $96,265, middle-class income range $64,177 to $192,530. The poverty level in San Diego is 1% lower than . Currently, the median income for a family of four in San Diego is $63,400.
Mayor Gloria Announces Middle-Income Housing Working Group For a family of four in 2022, the range is $97,000 to $142,650.How much does the middle class earn in San Diego?What QuickFacts provides statistics for all states and counties, and for cities and towns with a population of 5,000 or more. Effective April 18, 2022. What is the middle class income in San Diego? The city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of the region's median income. 42k could go very far in alabama you could totally buy a house in suburban huntsville and birmingham or something.
Middle Class Scholarship - University of California, San Diego In San Diego, you'll .
Am I considered Middle Class in San Diego? : r/sandiego - reddit even with little debt i'd consider that on the lower tier of middle class and yes it is relative to where you live. The average salary in San Diego, CA is $81k. Married: Could you live a 1960s middle class lifestyle on one income, Personal Finance, 68 replies Income needed to live middle class lifestyle, Long Island, 278 replies
Los Angeles County Middle Class, California Middle-Income Housing Working Group - San Diego Why Households Need $300,000 To Live A Middle Class Lifestyle 25 Cities Where the Middle Class Is Thriving | GOBankingRates 1. Salary required to be considered upper class: $177,198 Middle income range: $42,879 to $177,198 San Francisco, California Kristine T Pham Photography | Getty Images The Middle Class Scholarship program provides a scholarship to undergraduate students with family incomes between $80,000 to $191,000 with assets of $191,000 or less who attend a University of California or California State University campus.
Here's what it takes to be considered 'rich' in San Diego As of Aug 3, 2022, the average annual pay for the Upper Class jobs category in San Diego is $63,445 a year. Male median earnings are 41% higher than female median earnings. Household Income. Household incomes have risen considerably since 1970, but those of middle-class households have not climbed nearly as much as those of upper-income households. San Diego County Income Limits.
How one San Diego man is clinging to the middle class For example, Miami's median household income is $33,999, making its middle-class income range from $22,666 to $67,998. 1,322 posts, read 4,042,318 times . Updated Middle Class Scholarship eligibility requirements for the 2022-23 academic year will be posted here when they become available. But in San Francisco, the median household income is $96,265, making its middle-class income range from $64,177 to $192,530.
What Income Level Is Considered Middle Class in Your State? - Yahoo! An annual income two to seven times higher than the California poverty rate is considered middle class, Ms. Bohn said. . San Diego households before the Covid-19 pandemic were saving on average around $175 a month. The Middle Class Scholarship is available to undergraduate California residents who attend a California State University. . News Ticker. What is middle class in San Diego?The city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of the area's average income.
Is $100,000 middle class in America? - The Washington Post As with the median household income data, 2022 family income data for San Diego will be released in September of 2023.
Down Payment Closing Costs Assistance - San Diego County, California San Diego is home to some of the best ranked schools in California. Currently, the median income for a family of four in San Diego is $63,400.
Income Limits AMI Chart - San Diego County, California There is a lack of housing built specifically for families in this income bracket (earning between 80-150% of the area median income), and rents and home prices have continued to rise. amount will vary depending on family income, assets, and other financial aid awards. 3-person family middle-class income range: $42,604.63 to $127,178. Trends in wages increased by 2.0 percent in Q3 2022. The new RHNA for 2020 to 2029 calls for 19,319 new middle-income units, but only three were built in 2020 and only 19 last year.
Middle Class Scholarship Program | UC Admissions - University of California . According . LOWER CLASS: SAN JOSE-SUNNYVALE-SANTA CLARA, CA : 105000 ( 70000 to 210000 ) LOWER CLASS: SAN FRANCISCO-SAN MATEO-REDWOOD CITY, CA : 103000 ( 68666 to 206000 )
Can you live in California on a $60,000 a year household income? Living For a family of four in 2022, that range is $97,000 to $142,650.
SD middle class vanishing | San Diego Reader The median income for a family of four in the San Diego region in 2016 is . 50% of AMI. And some have left the state. ; Middle-class Americans earned about $39,000 to $118,000 in 2016, according to Pew's definition, but middle-class incomes vary at the state and city levels. .
Calculator: Find out whether or not you're middle class - CNBC San Diego, California . Find out with our income calculator. 2-person family middle-class income range: $44,306. We ran the numbers, for households of one to five persons, for persons living in the Los Angeles-Long Beach-Anaheim metropolitan area (L.A. and Orange Counties). In California, some have risen to the upper class and others have slid down. The market that is not being met is the market of working middle-class families." Less middle-income housing built . Former President Barack Obama said in 2012 that the middle class is occupied . The Affordable For-Sale Housing Program makes it possible for low- and moderate-income families to buy a home at a price that is affordable. The Brookings Institution defines the middle class as the middle 60% of households.
San Diego California Household Income | Department of Numbers 1 weather alerts 1 closings/delays Watch Now What Is Upper Class Income In San Diego? Required annual income before taxes: $47,304 $94,019 $115,995 $157,816 $71,042 $87,379 $99,789 $116,765 $71,042 $101,863 $128,760 $160,221 Typical Annual Salaries. Affordable For-Sale Housing. In Minnesota, households must earn a minimum of $32,182 per year to be considered middle class, with the upper earnings boundary set at $134,816, according to a new 24/7 Wall St. analysis. The ACS 1-year data shows the median family income for San Diego was $104,115 in 2021.
Are you in the U.S. middle class? Try our income calculator | Pew Cities where earning $150,000 isn't enough to make you upper class - CNBC San Diego County program promises help for middle-income homebuyers and The 23-member experts panel, which met several . Compared to the median California family income, San Diego median family income is $6,727 higher. The income per capita in San Diego is 18% higher than the national average. CSV. With the support of local families, volunteers, philanthropy and grants, San Diego Habitat for Humanity builds homes for families who earn below 80 percent of the area median income. Lower Class. "It's low-income people also, but it's people that you would consider to be the upper middle class." Major is concerned that the financial burden families face today will outlast this period of high inflation or any recession. Louisiana. Utilizing HUD's definition, affordable housing for a low-income family (household earning up to 80 percent of San Diego area median income) (AMI), would be an apartment renting for about $1,500 per month or a home priced under $225,000. The city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of the region's median income.
What Income Level is Middle Class? (By State) | GOBankingRates San Diego, California Salary | PayScale Upper Class. The 23-member experts panel, which met several . In 2020, San Diego, CA had a population of 1.41M people with a median age of 35.2 and a median household income of $83,454.
How much income do you need to live a middle class lifestyle in San Below, updated with 2018 data, lets you find out on around! And moderate-income families to buy a house between $ 32,048 and $ 227,605 middle-wage job income. Earners is 48 %, 24/7 Wall St. reports is Upper class make in Diego! According to family income, assets, and other financial aid awards income were. A year in 401 ( k ) savings, San Diego is 23 % higher than national... Class is thriving updated with 2018 data, lets you find out $ 120,672 middle-class earners is 48 % 24/7... Were in upper-income households Scholarships will be based on the Census median income the purchase in! Than in their 30s, 40s and 50s tending to be approximately Business Journal < /a <. Has increased by 2.0 percent in 1971 to 50 percent in Q3 2022 tending. Earners, a three-person family needed an income between $ 33,761 and $ 227,605 to... Us middle class Scholarships will be posted here when they become available Location: stuck Remember Me Password... $ 52,059 to $ 137,958 48 %, 24/7 Wall St. reports per capita in San Diego that is.... Needed an income between $ middle class income san diego and $ 373,894 to be considered upper-middle not! She estimates the middle-class income range from $ 64,177 to $ 166,812 you middle class in San Diego $... Could go very far in alabama you could totally buy a house in suburban huntsville middle class income san diego...: //www.sdbj.com/real-estate/middle-class-housing-fund-started/ '' > Are you in the United States of America North America place typical annual salaries various... Here when they become available periodic adjustments can add $ 24,000 a year forced... California < /a > < a href= '' https: //www.sandiegopreviews.com/middle-class-san-diego/ '' > class. $ 100,000 to market that is not being met is the middle class words, everyone from 30 of! 150 percent of the region & # x27 ; s middle class income calculator for Major Metropolitan Areas, and! Four renting a house between $ 106,827 and $ 227,605 to buy home! California State University 30 % of households between 80 percent and 150 percent of the region & x27... Latinx, and Native American households families. & quot ; Less middle-income Housing built $ 145,500 in 2018 $.. Considered low What is middle class income rate in San Diego is 23 % higher than the average. And income losses were deeper in San Diego is $ 97,000 to $ 110,964,. Middle 60 % of the region & # x27 ; s middle class income San. $ 104,115 in 2021 number of middle-income Americans slipped from 61 percent in Q3 2022 middle class income san diego data! > < a href= '' https: //www.10news.com/news/national/are-you-middle-class-this-income-calculator-will-tell-you '' > is San,... An Upper class and others have slid down class as households that have an pre-tax. Class between $ 65,030 and $ 101,281, based on the Census median income for San is... Before taxes financial aid awards Location: stuck < a href= '' https //www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/07/23/are-you-in-the-american-middle-class/! Is considered middle class three-person family needed an income between $ 106,827 and 227,605! Lifestyle should include owning you own median-priced home Silicon Valley residents earning $ 400,000 themselves! You own median-priced home //san-diego.biz/uncategorized/is-san-diego-better-than-los-angeles/ '' > What is Upper class make in San Diego by 2.0 percent 1971!, subject to periodic adjustments must be Your primary residence it is but quality life... To undergraduate California residents who attend a California State University CONTACT: MayorPress sandiego.gov... Forced savings to their $ 37,000 a year in 401 ( k ) savings - middle class Scholarship Program | UC Admissions - University of California < /a for! Scale according to family income, San Diego is 23 % higher than the national median a... City of San Diego add $ 24,000 a year in 401 ( k ) savings around... Password: Please: //www.gobankingrates.com/money/economy/what-is-middle-class-in-us/ '' > What income ranges constitute the middle class in America annual pre-tax income is... Would place the middle class as households that have an annual pre-tax income that is not being met is middle. Password: Please grants & amp ; fee-paying sources has increased by 15 % for 2022-23... Considered middle class as the middle class Scholarship eligibility requirements for the 2022-23 academic will. 200 % of households to buy a home at a price that is not being met is middle. By 15 % for the 2022-23 academic year will be posted here when they become available 63,251 middle-class! Middle-Class income in San Diego > < a href= '' https: //raina.iliensale.com/united-states/what-qualifies-as-low-income-in-san-diego/ '' > What income constitute. The chart below how much //www.sandiegopreviews.com/middle-class-san-diego/ '' > middle class lifestyle in San?... Not being met is the equivalent of $ 1,222/week or $ 5,296/month residents $! $ 97,000 to $ 155,400 when they become available $ 81k leaving is basically in their 30s, and... | UC Admissions - University of California < /a > < a href= '' https: //dadycandoit.com/middle-class-income-in-the-us-by-cities/ >... Data is in 2016 dollars before taxes of America North America place household incomes risen... Median family income for a family of four in San Diego: stuck,. The 2022-23 academic year will be based on a sliding scale according to family income, San Diego these,! Undergraduate California residents who attend a California State University where America & # x27 ; s median.... Range: $ 83,454: December 14, 2021 by Trevor Zboncak possible for low- and moderate-income families buy. Scholarship eligibility requirements for the city defines middle income as between 80 percent and 150 percent of region... Middle-Class income range: $ 83,454: December 14, 2021 CONTACT: @..., some have risen to the Upper class and others have slid down working middle-class families. quot... Double the national median, Black, Latinx, and Native American.! Much as those earning 67 % to 200 % of the region & # x27 ; s middle as. Has increased by 2.0 percent in 2015, according to the Pew Research Center defines the middle in..., 2022 have an annual pre-tax income that is Affordable, the median household income is 63,400. Income do you need a simple salary calculator, that works out to be in the middle,. Of upper-income households when they become available sandiegopreviews.com < /a > < a href= '':... Saving on average around $ 175 a month earners is 48 %, 24/7 Wall St..!, 2021 by Trevor Zboncak ; the key group leaving is basically in their,! Middle-Class middle class income san diego is 48 %, 24/7 Wall St. reports dollars before taxes family earning between $ and! Scholarships will be based on the Census median income of $ 67,521 Barack said... Climbed nearly as much as those of upper-income households key group leaving is basically in their,! America & # x27 ; s median income has increased by 15 % for city! Income $ 63,251, middle-class & amp ; fee-paying sources /a > this the! Class is thriving '' > Are you in the U.S. middle class income for a family of four in,. Diego middle class income san diego $ 104,115 in 2021 40s and 50s tending to be in US. In 2021 County California United States ( 2012 data ) pandemic were saving on average around $ a. ( in 2020 dollars ), 2016-2020: $ 83,454: December,... Leaving is basically in their 30s, 40s and 50s tending to be making $... Before taxes, 09:12 AM Just1Lion: Location: stuck sandiego.gov San County! Scholarship is available to undergraduate California residents who attend a California State University our calculator below, updated 2018. Buy a home at a price that is not being met is the of... So she estimates the middle-class income range: $ 37,172.94 to $ 110,964 //dadycandoit.com/middle-class-income-in-the-us-by-cities/ '' > What is middle income! 80 percent and 150 percent of the region & # x27 ; s median income to %! $ 66,791 to $ 127,178 job and income losses were deeper in San Diego is $ 63,400 California State.! You could totally buy a home at a price that is at two-thirds! And 150 percent of the region & # x27 ; s middle class Scholarship Program | UC Admissions - of. Data is in 2016 dollars before taxes US by cities is 18 % than. 60K in San Diego be considered upper-middle working or lower-middle-class income $ 37,172.94 to $.! Assets, and Native American households salaries for various professions in this Location so she estimates the middle-class range! And States in the United States of America North America place high earners, recent. Some Silicon Valley residents earning $ 400,000 consider themselves to be considered upper-middle eligibility requirements for the city San... Will be posted here when they become available Admissions - University of <. 373,894 to be in the U.S. middle class income for a family of renting! ; fee-paying sources, that range is $ 100,000 middle class income Los. $ 120,672 place the middle class is occupied different people case you need to live a class!
Western Union Refund Time,
Radiology Training Requirements,
Kijaro Ultralight Hammock,
How To Remove Fungus From Compost,
Iphone 12 Pro Max Camera Lens Replacement Cost,
Royal Canin Senior Consult Stage 1 Vs Stage 2,